Breaking Open the Black Box

The Secrets and Stories of Game Design

Pages

  • Game Design Lessons
  • Learning From My Past
  • Post-Mortems
  • Who am I?
Follow @Xelnath [mc4wp_form]

Powered by Genesis

Archives for June 2012

Who Were My Teachers?

2012.06.09 by Xelnath

As flattering as it is to wish otherwise, I am only here because of the incredible influence of the people who have filled my life. Every person I meet gives me a shard of something new. This is a short list of a few from my past who have had the greatest impact:
Right: Tom Cadwell

Tom Cadwell (Zileas)

Tom and I were roommates and before that internet friends through Starcraft. Tom’s example by starting his own company (Ethermoon Entertainment) encouraged me to explore game design as a realistic life option. Similarly, as he learned from his own mistakes, he shared the seeds that became the framework for improving my own designs.

Later he invited me to the beta tests for the games he worked on for Blizzard Entertainment. After going back to college for his MBA, Tom Cadwell joined up with Marc Merrill, Colt Hallum, Steve Mescon and several others and founded Riot Games, known for the incredibly successful League of Legends.

Justin Crites (Xiphoris)

When the World of Warcraft Beta started, UI modification was close to anarchy. No two people could adjust the UI without utterly stomping on the other. Justin originally proposed a confederation of the most passionate developers and the hardware to host our projects. Incredibly inspirational, Justin enlisted me early on to help organize and manage the addons while he recruited additional authors.

He was also wise enough to take my advice that the name “Cosmos” was a better one than “EverythingScript”. As with all passions, Justin moved on and is now a senior software developer for Amazon.

Bill Dyess (Thott)

Possibly the most well-read man I have ever met, Bill understood two things well – the scope of technology and the power of reducing the barrier to entry. When Justin and I were struggling to make our scripts available to the growing World of Warcraft player base, Bill offered hardware in exchange for letting him datamine our users. I shot him down completely the first time.

Wise as he was, he came back a few weeks later, this time offering a one-stop solution which automated our patching woes, allowed users to regularly update before launching the game and made the data mining an opt-in feature, which gave users credit for the items they found. I relented and Bill became an incredible mentor.

From technology, to health and love, he always had words of experience. Bill created Thottbot, and handled all of the controversy created by such a site. After some legal issues, Bill retired the site to manage his ISP business and I remain impressed with the degree of commitment he has shown to his family since then.

Michael Heiberg

When I first started at Blizzard Entertainment, I knew little of the people who worked there, only that they made incredible things. In a company like Blizzard, individually glory is often discarded to the credit of the whole.  Mike is the living incarnation of this philosophy – always passing on the glory while doing his best to support those who seek it.

Mike was my first mentor at Blizzard and taught me much about the important of attention to detail in our work. Mike knew more about the “why” things were done than perhaps any other designer at Blizzard. If you ever thought casting a Fireball was a simple thing, you need only need ask Mike about all of the parts that make it relevant, important and responsive.

While training me, Mike wrote an incredibly detailed document that continues to live on the World of Warcraft Wiki to this day, given to each new encounter designer when they start out. While many of the lessons are missed, it persists as a prime example of the level of thought Mike put into everything he created.

Wyatt Cheng

There are few people who have been properly instructed in the Wyatt Cheng school of Game Design… and I wasn’t one of them. However, I don’t think any other designer has had as much indirect influence on my work. Wyatt Cheng is most famously known for the statement “Any horrible mechanic, no matter how bad, is considered fun if sufficiently overpowered.”

When I started at Blizzard, I frequently compared my work against his. Wyatt’s work regularly espoused the virtues of visible game mechanics, avoidable damage and using numbers to create emotional tension. Wyatt’s greatest virtue is his ability to create situations that allow players to exploit his game mechanics while promoting challenge and tension in his work.

Wyatt is also incredibly talented at encouraging and accepting feedback. He famously said the words: “No feedback is wrong, but you should never act on more than 25% of it.”

Darren F. and Rob Bridgman

While not directly connected to the games industry, I want to give a quick shout out to the two guys who taught me the importance of both embracing who you are and accepting that your identity is a fluid, growing concept.

Rob taught me what it was to be accepted. Darren taught me the difference between making a joke and being one. They both drove me to take risks and grow as a person.

Not surprisingly, Rob and Darren both served our nation in the armed forces and I have been incredibly fortunate to have crossed paths with both of you.

Mom and Dad (And Family)

I love you both. You taught me well, even when you taught me wrong. Enough said.

Why is this important?

While we’re all alone in deciding to change, the people who support us along the way make the process infinitely more bearable.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

The First Step in Mastery

2012.06.03 by Xelnath

If you’re reading this, there are two possibilities:
  1. You’ll remember some piece of what you’ve read.
  2. You’ll be part of the majority who roll their eyes and keep moving.

I believe you’re one of the former – and it’s for you that I’m writing this:

Masters are not masters because they can do flashy things. Masters are masters because they have the freedom  and bandwidth to do flashy things.  This freedom is born of one thing:

Completely and utterly ingraining the basics of their medium into their habits.

As a child, I was constantly attracted to the flashy, the unique and exotic. This is the natural way our bodies respond to the environment around it. I soon learned that flashy tricks didn’t lead to good craftsmanship any more than food dye makes a cake delicious.

To truly understand how to make a great game, you must first understand its mechanics. To understand great mechanics, you must first understand the basic ones.

This is the philosophy from which everything I can hope to teach is born.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

What is a Master?

2012.06.03 by Xelnath


When you stop and think about a person who has mastered their craft, we nerds often think of ancient swordsmen, incredible artists and powerful orators. The next step is often to describe a masterpiece created by  their handiwork.

Bruno Walpoth is a great example of a traditional master. His incredibly lifelike figures are the work of hundreds of hours of toiling away at the these masterpieces.

When you stop and look at this single work, you can instantly see the masterful craftsmanship, attention to detail and eye for lighting that went into the creation and presentation of his beautiful figures.

While anyone can agree that his work is incredible, it is nearly impossible for you or I to look at this and know what it takes to become a master sculptor of wood. An experienced wood worker might have a little bit more luck – they could describe his techniques, the choice of wood or varnish used to coat it.

It is ultimately this gap in knowledge, tools and experience that causes us to separate ourselves from those we call masters.  And it is this separation that prevents us from reaching out and trying to close that gap.

So let me show you someone else I view as a prime example of a master:

“Wait, are you serious, Alex? A street performer?”

Yes. If you wish to understand what is that defines a master, you need look no further. This man has taken the simplest of side jobs and turned it into a thing of beauty.  The great thing about this man, is that there is no doubt in the minds of anyone that they can make cotton candy.

Cotton candy is pretty easy. Reach into a machine, pour in the sugar, swirl a paper baton and viola – a delicious dental problem!

So what is it that separates how we’d make cotton candy from him? Let’s point out the obvious first.

  • He’s dancing
  • He can make cotton candy in multiple shapes
  • He can weave the candy a long distance away from the basin
  • He freely gives away bits of the candy
Are you still with me?
These are the surface level behaviours that indicate his mastery to us. The next step is to understand what they mean. 
  • Dancing
    1. He enjoys what he does
    2. He is healthy and effective  
    3. He can afford the extra effort of dancing in addition to performing the basic task
  • Shape Control
    1. He has done this many times before
    2. He doesn’t limit himself to producing the same thing repeatedly
    3. He remembers the details to control the outcome
  • Distance
    1. He can influence the material indirectly
    2. He has pushed the limits of what he can create
    3. He knows how far he can go and still produce a product
  • Giveaway
    1. He knows how to keep a crowd nearby
    2. He keeps those who watch engaged in the performance
    3. He has an abundance mentality
Now take these qualities and project them onto any master you know. Often, if you experiences are like mine, you’ll see they express the same qualities.
A successful business friend of mine said to me, “Starting a business wasn’t really that hard. Becoming the kind of person who could run a business was.”
Wise words. 

Filed Under: Uncategorized

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • Next Page »

Archives

  • August 2022
  • July 2019
  • October 2018
  • May 2018
  • February 2018
  • June 2017
  • February 2017
  • November 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • May 2016
  • March 2016
  • December 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • July 2014
  • June 2014
  • January 2014
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • January 2012
  • September 1816